Car Accident Questions • 6 of 40

Should I Talk to Insurance Before Hiring a Lawyer After a Georgia Car Accident?

What to tell your own insurer, and why to pause before giving the other side a recorded statement.

GUARD UP
RECORDED

By Ibrahim J. Awad, The Karate Attorney • November 18, 2026

The phone usually rings within a day or two. A friendly voice says she is from the other driver’s insurance company. She is sorry about the accident. She just wants to “get your side of the story” and asks if it is okay to record the call.

Most people say yes. So people ask me all the time whether they should talk to insurance before hiring a lawyer. My honest answer has two parts, because there are two very different insurance companies in your life right now.


Do I Have to Report the Accident to My Own Insurance Company in Georgia?

Yes. Your own policy is a contract, and almost every policy requires you to report a crash promptly and cooperate. If you wait too long or refuse, you can give your own company a reason to deny coverage you paid for, like collision coverage for your car or MedPay for your medical bills.

So call your own insurer. Give them the basics: the date, the time, the location, the other driver’s information, and the police report number if you have it. Keep it to facts you actually know.

What you do not need to do on that first call is guess about speeds, injuries, or fault. “I am still being evaluated by a doctor” is a complete and honest answer.


Should I Give a Recorded Statement to the Other Driver’s Insurance?

This is where I ask people to slow down.

The other driver’s insurance company does not owe you anything under a contract. You are not their customer. Georgia law does not require you to give them a recorded statement, and in most cases I recommend you do not give one before you have talked with a Georgia car accident lawyer.

A recorded statement is an audio recording of you answering their questions. It stays in their file for the life of the claim.

Here is what I see happen. Two days after the wreck, a client is sore but still running on adrenaline. The adjuster asks, “How are you feeling?” The client says, “I’m okay.” Three weeks later, an MRI shows a herniated disc. Now the insurance company has a recording of that same person saying they were okay.

Friendly is part of the job. So is protecting her company’s money.


What Is the Adjuster’s Job, Really?

I want to be fair here. Many adjusters are decent, hardworking professionals, and I negotiate respectfully with them every week.

But respect does not change the scoreboard. The adjuster is evaluating your claim for the company that insures the person who hit you. Every dollar they do not pay you is a dollar their company keeps.

Questions are often designed to lock in details early: Where were you looking? Had you been to a doctor for your back before?

An innocent answer, given while you are in pain, on medication, or simply rattled, can be twisted into an argument that you were partly at fault. In Georgia, that matters. Under our comparative fault rules, your recovery can be reduced by your share of the blame, and if you are found 50 percent or more at fault, you recover nothing.

In my dojo, the first thing we teach a new student is to keep their guard up. Not because everyone in the room wants to hurt you, but because you never drop your hands while someone across from you is still throwing. Talking to the other side’s adjuster before you understand your rights is fighting with your hands at your waist.


What Should I Say If the Adjuster Calls Before I Hire a Lawyer?

You can be polite and still protect yourself. Try something like this:

“Thank you for calling. I am not ready to give a recorded statement right now. Please send me your name, your claim number, and your contact information in writing.”

You are not being difficult. You are being careful. You do not have to discuss injuries, fault, or your medical history.

A few more things I tell people:

  • Do not sign any medical authorization the other insurer sends you. Some of those forms allow access to years of unrelated medical records.
  • Do not accept a quick check for your injuries before you know how badly you are hurt. Once you sign a release, the claim is usually over for good.
  • It is generally fine to work with insurance on your car repair or rental. Just keep those conversations about the car.

When Should I Call a Georgia Car Accident Lawyer?

Ideally, before you talk to the other driver’s insurance at all. That does not mean you must hire anyone. It means you should get a free consultation so you understand the board before you make a move. (If you are worried about timing, here is how long you have to hire a lawyer in Georgia.)

When someone hires our firm, we send a letter of representation to the insurance companies. From that point on, the adjuster talks to us, not you. Our attorneys handle those conversations, and you get to focus on getting better. You will always know the name of your attorney, and our Client Care team answers texts usually within minutes.

Whether you were hurt in Marietta, Dalton, Lawrenceville, or anywhere else in Georgia, the consultation is free, and we answer 24/7. Call or text us at (706) 890-0000 for a free consultation before you give anyone a recorded statement. Even if we are not the right fit, you will hang up knowing exactly what to say and what not to say.

Keep Your Hands Up,

Ibrahim J. Awad
The Karate Attorney | The Awad Law Firm, P.C.


Talk to Us Free. Pay Nothing Unless We Win.

A real person answers 24/7 by phone or text. Se habla español.

706-890-0000